Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2022) 05 AFT CK 0014

Arjun Kumar Patel vs Union of India & Ors

Armed Forces Tribunal · Decided on 18 May 2022

HON’BLE JUDGES
Rajendra Menon, Chairperson, (J) · P.M. Hariz, Member (A)
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
OA 1893/2020 with MA 2190/2020

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

6 paragraphs · 321 words
1.

On  02.02.2022,     an     objection     was     raised     by     the respondents     with     regard     to     the     maintainability    of    this application    in    view    of   the    Full    Bench   judgement    dated 28.05.2021 passed by this Tribunal in the case of Rect Kaptan Singh Vs. Union of India and Ors. [0.A. No.  17 of 2015 and other  connected  matters'.  The  matter  was  directed  to  be listed  for  consideration  on 14.03.2022.  On 14.03.2022,  the matter was adjourned at the instance of the applicant.    Today also, counsel for the applicant is not present.    A prayer for an adjournment is made by the proxy counsel appearing on his behalf.  However,  on  going  through  the  prayer made  in  the application,   we   find   that   the   applicant  has   prayed   for  the following reliefs in Para 8:

(a)  The   Honble   Tribunal   may   kindly   be   pleased   to direct   the   respondents   to   get   the   height   of  the applicant   be   measured   at   Base   Hospital,   Delhi Cantt. Or any other Govt. Hospital, and/or;

(b)  The   Honble  Tribunal  may  kindly  be  pleased  to direct the respondents to give appointment letter to the applicant to join the Soldier Technical Post for which he has applied. And/or;

(c)  The   Hon ble  Tribunal  may  kindly  be  pleased  to direct the  Respondents to initiate an  enquiry and take  disciplinary  action  the  person  in  charge  for arbitrary and illegally declaring the Applicant unfit. And/or;

(d)  To     pass     any     such     further    order    or    orders, direction/directions  as  this  Honble  Tribunal  may deem fit and proper in accordance with law.

2.

Apparently,   the   matter   pertains   to   recruitment   and appointment of the applicant on the Soldier Technical post and in view of the Full Bench decision in the case of Rect. Kaptan Singh etc. (supra), we do not have the jurisdiction to deal with the  matter  and  accordingly,  we  dismiss  the  OA.  However, liberty  is  granted  to  the  applicant to  take  recourse  to  such remedy  as  may  be  available  to  him  before  the  appropriate Forum as per law.