High CourtsSingle Bench(2021) 08 UK CK 0096

Mahendra Singh Rana vs Cantonment Board, Dehradun

Uttarakhand High Court · Decided on 6 August 2021

HON’BLE JUDGES
Raghvendra Singh Chauhan, CJ
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Arbitration Application No. 21 Of 2020

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

73 paragraphs · 404 words

S. No.,Work Order,"Amount/Value

(in INR)",Amount of Bill (in INR),Date of Bill

1.,"Improvement of children park

and shops below Cantt. Octroi

Post Kailana (05th April,

2017)","1,29,98,000/-","12,58,593.93/-",

2.,"Repairs of 6 Nos. Old

dustbins at various places in

Cantt. Area (18th September,

2017)","6,37,800/-","6,64,930.07/-",25.06.2018

3.,"Providing 10 Nos. Dustbin at

various places in Cantt. Area

and parapet wall (18th

September, 2017)","4,93,310/-","5,06,437.95/-",20.06.2018

4.,"Providing street light point in

Cantt. Area 10 Nos. (17th

November, 2017)","6,06,900/-","6,46,295.48/-",20.06.2018

5.,"Providing fencing of angle iron

and barbed wire around Patia

Dhar Cantt. Garden (17th

November, 2017)","55,04,000/-","19,03,150/-",30.12.2018

6.,"Shops into Community Hall

below Cantt. Oct. Post

Kailana (Children Park) (5th

March, 2018)","17,79,000/-","19,56,900/-",30.12.2018

7.,"Three Boar Well Flate at

Cantt. Area (05th March,

2018)","10,24,200/-","11,04,111.50/-",28.06.2018

8.,"Providing white washing etc.

of Cantt. Fund Qtrs,

School’s Office Board

Room parapet wall retaining

wall (CBR 23rd May, 2018)","23,12,800/-","25,14,167.83/-",21.03.2019

9.,"Repairs to retaining wall

which has been totally

damaged due to heavy rainfall

below Chinta Haran Temple

(14th October, 2018)","1,84,600/-","1,94,075.95/-",26.10.2018

10.,"Retaining Wall for perfect

erosion below hill side building

path of Children Park to

damage due to heavy rainfall

(14th October, 2018)","11,10,900/-","12,09,935.35/-",28.10.2018

11.,"Providing mild steel railing and

flooring and chequered tiles at

Children Park Kailana (14th

October, 2018)","18,18,100/-","19,83,666.27/-",27.10.2018

12.,"Providing retaining wall at

Khadra Patiya Dhar Garden

Road damaged due to

landslide by heavy rainfall

(14th October, 2018)","8,52,300/-","6,69,868.28/-",29.10.2018

13.,"Protect Road by wire

mattresses at Khadra Patiya

Dhar Garden Road damaged

due to landslide by heavy

rainfall (14th October, 2018)","1,54,700/-","1,68,776.21/-",25.10.2018

14.,"Estimate for repair to retaining

wall which has been totally

damaged due to heavy rainfall

at Bear Goudown above

Safaiwala Qtrs. and shops

(14th October, 2018)","7,34,500/-","7,59,202.98/-",03.03.2019

Total Amount of Works,,"3,02,11,110/-","1,55,40,112.19/-",

contention raised by the learned counsel for the respondent is clearly unacceptable.,,,,

19.

Admittedly, the disputes continue to exist between the parties. Obviously, the dispute needs to be resolved through the arbitral proceedings.",,,,

Therefore, this Court appoints Mr. B.C. Kandpal, Retd. Judge, High Court of Uttarakhand, R/o 117 Rajeshwar Nagar, Phase-I, Sahastradhara Road,",,,,

Dehradun, as the sole Arbitrator after his disclosure in writing is obtained in terms of Section 11(8) of the Act; and only after receipt thereof, shall his",,,,

appointment, as an arbitrator, come into force.",,,,

20.

On giving consent to arbitrate the disputes between the parties, Mr. B.C. Kandpal, Retd. Judge, High Court of Uttarakhand, R/o 117 Rajeshwar",,,,

Nagar, Phase-I, Sahastradhara Road, Dehradun, shall enter reference, and shall pass an award in accordance with law. The learned arbitrator shall",,,,

fix his fees in consultation with both the parties.,,,,

21.

The arbitration application is disposed of accordingly.,,,,