High CourtsSingle Bench(2021) 02 GUJ CK 0020

Yusufbhai Ismailbhai Motiwala vs State Of Gujarat

Gujarat High Court · Decided on 5 February 2021

HON’BLE JUDGES
Ashutosh J. Shastri, J
RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Misc.Application (Modification/Deletion Of Condition) No. 1 Of 2021 In R/Criminal Misc.Application No. 13522 Of 2020

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

39 paragraphs · 861 words

Ashutosh J. Shastri, J

1.

The present application is filed for the purpose of seeking modification/deletion of conditions contained in paragraph No.6 (f), (g) and (h) at least for

a period of two months since the applicant is required to visit USA for the purpose of complying with the conditions attached to the Green Card. It has

been stated in the application that two sons of the present applicant are settled down in USA since number of years, particulars whereof are given on

oath in paragraph 2 and the applicant is going to stay with his sons at New York, who are doing the business of gold and jewelery. It has been stated

before the Court that if the applicant will not be permitted to visit USA, then there will be an adverse effect on applicant's Green Card. Hence, there is

a necessity to travel urgently. The applicant has further stated in the application that in past, practically every year, the applicant has visited USA and

it is only on account of this criminal case, the modification is required to be sought against the order of grant of bail. It has further been stated that the

criminal case is not likely to be over within near future and if by that time, the applicant will not visit, the applicant will have to surrender the Green

Card and as such, there is dire necessity of travel to USA by the applicant.

2.

On receipt of this application, the Court on 03.02.2021 has issued notice and pursuant to it, learned Additional Public Prosecutor Mr. J. K. Shah

appearing on behalf of the authority has stated and voiced out some apprehensions through the written instructions dated 04.02.2021 signed by the

Police Inspector, Amreli City Police Station that the applicant may not return to India once the permission is granted. But then, as against this

apprehension voiced out, learned advocate Mr. Ashish Dagli appearing on behalf of the applicant has submitted that except this criminal case, there

are no antecedents of the present applicant and further, he is ready and willing to abide by any of the conditions which may be imposed upon him

while permitting the applicant to travel to USA for temporary period. Learned advocate Mr. Dagli has assured on instructions that the applicant is

ready and willing to file an undertaking before the trial court within a period of three days that the applicant will return to India on 05.04.2021 and will

surrender his passport again to the trial court where the case is pending. The undertaking will also be to the effect that the ownership papers related to

residential house and other properties situated in India will be surrendered in the court concerned till the applicant returns to India and in addition

thereto, the applicant is also ready and willing to deposit Rs.2.50 Lacs as part of surety. Upon these conditions along with other whatever suitable

conditions which may be imposed upon the applicant, he is ready and willing to abide by the same and specifically undertakes before this Court that

the applicant will surrender himself by 06.04.2021 and will redeposit the passport in the court concerned.

3.

To this submission made by learned advocate Mr. Ashish Dagli for the applicant, learned Additional Public Prosecutor Mr. J. K. Shah appearing on

behalf of the authority has no much grievance thereafter since the grievance voiced out by the authority is taken care of by such kind of conditions has

left it to the discretion of the Court to pass suitable orders in the interest of justice.

4.

Having heard learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and having gone through the aforesaid submissions and material placed before

the Court, this application deserves to be allowed by suitably modifying the conditions contained in paragraph No. 6(f), (g) and (h) mentioned in order

dated 06.11.2020 for a period from 06.02.2021 till 06.04.2021. Accordingly, following are the conditions which the applicant undertook to abide by :Â​

4.1 The applicant shall deposit an amount of Rs.2.50 Lacs before the trial court where the case is pending along with an undertaking in specific form

that the applicant will return to India and redeposit the passport on 06.04.2021.

4.2 The applicant shall also surrender his papers related to ownership of the properties which the applicant is belonging in the trial court along with the

aforesaid undertaking and upon such filing of undertaking and deposit of an amount, the passport of the applicant will be handed over till 05.04.2021

and thereby, the applicant is permitted to travel to USA.

4.3 The applicant shall also file an specific affidavit in the court concerned indicating about the status of his sons with whom the applicant is going to

reside in USA and will furnish the current address residence of his sons and related particulars.

5.

Upon aforesaid compliance of the conditions, up to 05.04.2021, the conditions attached to the order dated 06.11.2020 contained in paragraph

No.6(f) (g) and (h) shall remain suspended and modified and upon return to the country, the applicant shall surrender his passport on 06.04.2021

without fail.

6.

Accordingly, the present application stands allowed. Direct service is permitted.